When I was in primary school, I read as many Banana Books as I could get my hands on. Earlier a boiled egg reminded me of the eggs in Scaredy-Cat, which reminded me of one of my favourite Banana Books, The Quest of the Golden Dragon. The book follows the adventures of a group of pirates and their cabin boy, Sharp, to find the golden dragon treasure. As I remember it, at the end of the book it's discovered that Sharp is, in fact, a girl: she'd run away from an orphanage, and passed herself off as a cabin boy to live a new life at sea. She begs the pirates to not return her to the orphanage. If I recall correctly, the story ends with the pirates relaxing in a tavern while Sharp, now with longer hair and wearing a dress, serves them drinks.
So. A girl dresses as a boy, fair enough. She has to pass herself off as a boy to be accepted on the pirate ship, sad but okay. When she's discovered, the pirates treat her as a girl - in a stereotypically female role. It no longer matters that she played a large part in helping the pirates both on board the ship and during their treasure-seeking quest, as a girl she must now take the role of serving drinks. Never mind that the pirates know that she's capable as a member of the crew - this is seemingly forgotten as soon as her gender is revealed. She must conform to the feminine image that society has placed on her: her change of hairstyle and dress to a more 'girly' style alludes to this. We don't know how she feels about this, perhaps she embraces the chance to show her femininity: it isn't discussed how comfortable she was when presenting as a boy. While she may embrace being able to show her girly side (if she has one) by wearing a dress and growing her hair, does she enjoy having the role of a waitress given to her? Or would she rather continue having adventures at sea, with nobody viewing her as unladylike?
Positive message: Through determination and involving every member of a team, any challenge can be overcome and rewards will be found.
Negative messages: Girls must be 'girly', gender is more important than capability, we must conform to gender roles, and learning something new about a person makes their previous actions irrelevant.
So. A girl dresses as a boy, fair enough. She has to pass herself off as a boy to be accepted on the pirate ship, sad but okay. When she's discovered, the pirates treat her as a girl - in a stereotypically female role. It no longer matters that she played a large part in helping the pirates both on board the ship and during their treasure-seeking quest, as a girl she must now take the role of serving drinks. Never mind that the pirates know that she's capable as a member of the crew - this is seemingly forgotten as soon as her gender is revealed. She must conform to the feminine image that society has placed on her: her change of hairstyle and dress to a more 'girly' style alludes to this. We don't know how she feels about this, perhaps she embraces the chance to show her femininity: it isn't discussed how comfortable she was when presenting as a boy. While she may embrace being able to show her girly side (if she has one) by wearing a dress and growing her hair, does she enjoy having the role of a waitress given to her? Or would she rather continue having adventures at sea, with nobody viewing her as unladylike?
Positive message: Through determination and involving every member of a team, any challenge can be overcome and rewards will be found.
Negative messages: Girls must be 'girly', gender is more important than capability, we must conform to gender roles, and learning something new about a person makes their previous actions irrelevant.